Jump to: ZRecs Home | Z Recommends | PRIZEY | The Tranquil Parent | Punnybop | The ZRecs Guide to Safer Children's Products
Subscribe via RSS Get Z Recommends posts and links delivered free via RSS or email

  • As seen in

    Subscribe to posts


    Get our newsletter





New from thinkbaby: The sunscreen we’re using this year

New from thinkbaby: The sunscreen we’re using this year
You might be surprised to hear about the launch of a sunscreen by a company currently known for its infant feeding gear and adult water bottles. But if you know much about Think Operations, you won't be very surprised at all. A quick glance at ZRecs Guide listings for thinkbaby and thinksport products should make it clear that we're pretty impressed with everything we've seen - the 750 ml double-walled Thinksport bottle and game-changing BPA-free feeding set, which now has its best components sold as separates as well (you can find both of them in the ZRecs Guide). And the company does its research, and then some; thinksport water bottles were among the latest on the market with colors, because of their exacting paint requirements (they are now available in blue, green and purple as well as their original black and silver), and thinkbaby infant feeding bottles have not just BPA testing behind them but broader biological testing to verify the nature and quality of materials they're using.

We were excited to try out Think's new sunscreen, which has been in the works for roughly a year now. The zinc oxide-based sunscreen is sold in 3 oz. bottles branded as both thinkbaby sunscreen and thinksport sunscreen, on the logic that both athletes and parents care more than the average consumer about what they put in, and on, their bodies, and those they care for.

Ingredients


The ingredient list may come as something of a shock for consumers familiar with sunscreens rich with long-named chemicals; in fact, it reads more like the lists you'd find in a natural skin product, full of Latin and common plant names.

Active Ingredient: Zinc Oxide 25%. Inactive Ingredients: Distilled buffered water, vegetable glycerine, whole leaf aloe vera (Barbadensis) gel, Persea Gratissima (Avocado) Oil, Rubus Idaeus (Raspberry) Seed Oil, Doucus Carota, Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Oryza sativa, oryzinol, Olea Uropaea (Olive) Fruit Oil, cetaeryl glucoside, phosphatidyl choline (not soy lecithin) Lactoperoxidase, Glucose oxidase, aribinogalactan, arginine, vitamin E (Tocophero), vitamin C (ascorbic acid) Citrus Aurantium Dulcis (Orange) Peel Wax, Beeswax, Boswellia carteri, Potassium sorbate, rosemary (Rosmarinus Officinalis), cornstarch (Zea Mays), Maranta Arundinacea Root, Carageenan (Chondus crispus).


The sunscreen scored a 1 out of 10 for potential health hazards in the Environmental Working Group's annual sunscreen rankings. It uses no PEGs, not even sneaky ones from "natural" sources.

Equally impressive is this sunscreen's avoidance of nanomaterials. Many sunscreens use undeclared nano-sized active ingredients (titanium dioxide). Think's sunscreen uses zinc oxide with particle sizes over 100 microns.

Performance


The biggest question we had prior to receiving samples of thinkbaby/thinksport sunscreen was whether it would rub in cleanly or leave your skin ghostly white. But zinc oxide usage has come a long way since the white-nosed characters from 1980s beach comedies. With titanium dioxide, the main way companies have made it "invisible" on the skin is by using the ingredient at nanoparticle sizes. We have serious concerns about the use of nanoparticles in skin products, and recommend against them.

Think sunscreen does apply a bit differently from other sunscreens, which we consider par for the course for a product that has gone through this kind of reinvention. It has a slight tackiness or chalkiness to it, more like traditional zinc oxide sunscreens than like nano titanium dioxide sunscreens. You have to rub it into the skin to make its white color disappear. It does virtually disappear when rubbed in, although it leaves a very slight, faint, paleness - pale enough that you probably can't make it out in these photos.

Here's a small application of the thinksport-branded sunscreen on our daughter Z's arm.


And here's how it looks after rubbing it in.


Protection


Think's sunscreen has an SPF rating of 30+; as Julie Deardorff at the Chicago Tribune, among others, has reported, there has been a surge in sunscreens with dubious claims of SPF of 50 and above. More importantly, thinksport and thinkbaby sunscreen strikes a balance between UVA and UVB protection that should be checked in any sunscreen you intend to use. Some sunscreens with a high SPF have most of that protection in one form of UV light, leaving you more exposed to the other than you realize.

It is also very long-lasting. The FDA is putting guidelines into place that will ban the use of the term "waterproof," as it encourages users to go too long without reapplying sunscreen. But we have used this sunscreen at the beach, at swimming pools, and sweating out in the hot sun, and have noticed that it seems to remain on the skin for quite a while and through a lot of activity.

Price and competition


Think's new sunscreen retails for $16.99 for a three-ounce tube. This is comparable to Badger ($16 for 2.9 oz.), whose own mineral-based sunscreen scores well in EWG's assessments and another of our favorites. Consumers know that natural, mineral blocking sunscreens are more expensive than chemically protective sunscreens, which means the reapplication rate becomes the final judge of value. A $17 sunscreen that lasts several hours in one application is a better value than something that costs less per ounce but has to be applied every hour or two to protect your skin. Again, we feel neither qualified nor licensed to make any claims about how long this or any sunscreen lasts, but our own experience has us applying this sunscreen less frequently during an outing than some others we've used.

Many "natural" sunscreens rule themselves out of our safety book based on their reliance on nano-sized titanium dioxide. This material is euphemistically referred to as "sunscreen-grade" on ingredient labels, but that means the ingredient is used in the sunscreen at sizes less than 100 microns in size, which has potential health risks that are still being studied.

For more quick sunscreen recommendations, check out the ZRecs Guide's section on safer sunscreens. Please note that TruKid's Sunny Days sunscreen, one of our standbys last year and a product we still highly recommend, still is; its listing in EWG's Skin Deep database is out of date and includes several ingredients not in the sunscreen's current formulation.

You can buy thinkbaby sunscreen and thinksport sunscreen directly from thinkbaby and thinksport.
Share this post: Delicious | Digg | Facebook | Reddit | Stumble | Email
Categories: chemical safety, summer
11 Comments
1. Lynn [5/27/10]

I’m so glad you guys did a review on this.  I’ve been trying to find it and they have been out of stock for a while now.  Do you know if there is any difference between the sport and baby versions, or is it just labeling?  Also, do you know anything about the PHENOXYETHANOL in their ingredients list?  It says “naturally derived” but I was curious.

2. Ruta [5/27/10]

I’ve got a history of melanoma, so me and my fair-skinned, 4 year old daughter wear sunscreen everyday.  I was excited to try the ThinkSport sunscreen since we, too, love their other products.  For us, this sunscreen has not really worked that well… We’ve found it to be incredibly sticky - to the point that it is difficult to rub in - and that it does not hold up at the beach the way Kabana’s Green Screen or even Badger does.  Pretty much as soon as my daughter dipped a body part into the water, you could watch the ThinkSport washing away.  While we’ll use up the rest of the bottle, we won’t be buying more.

3. Shannon [5/27/10]

I tried some thinkbaby sunscreen from a sample tube at a local children’s boutique and liked the powdery feel of it, versus the somewhat oily feel of the California Baby and Badger sunscreens that we otherwise use. However, I couldn’t stand the smell of the thinkbaby sunscreen so I didn’t buy it. I’d love if they could come out with a version that doesn’t smell (and doesn’t use any pthalates to mask the smell, either!).

4. Christy [5/27/10]

Yay for the shout out to Badger!  I just did a review of their new unscented formula and love it.  Their reveiw would read very similar to ThinkBaby’s - they use larger nanoparticles, etc.

5. Brenna [5/31/10]

I am super excited about this new (safe) option. It is so hard to find good sunscreen, especially one without harmful ingredients.

6. Kate [6/04/10]

I wanted to love this sunscreen, I really did.  I bought a tube and much like Ruta above, we did not have luck.  It was incredibly sticky and did not soak into my baby’s skin.  It made her clothes completely sticky as well.  When she got into the baby pool about 45 minutes after application, I watched the sunscreen wash right off her skin.  I won’t be using the rest of the bottle.  I was very disapointed.

7. Brenna J. [6/07/10]

I’ve been trying to find a good sunscreen that won’t break the bank, and so far I’ve come up empty. After looking at some recipes online, I’ve decided to have a go at making it myself. The main ingredients (enough for several batches) can be purchased online for about the price of one of these bottles.

I wonder if you’ve ever considered this route?

8. Taylor B [6/07/10]

TruKid Natural Skincare is a good price and it is ALL Natural. Very healthy for your kids. The sunscreen has no Vitamin A and it goes on very smooth. It is great for sensitive skin and it smells great. A 2oz tube is nine dollars.

9. Jeremiah [6/09/10]

Brenna J, be warned - you are messing with some materials that are at their most dangerous as an inhalation hazard - nanoparticle or micronized titanium dioxide and/or zinc oxide. In other words, no, we wouldn’t do that, and we wouldn’t advise anyone else to, either.

Taylor B, we love TruKid.

Looking into some of these other comments. More soon.

10. Kathy [6/17/10]

Great review.  I too had the same impression of its chalkiness but it does perform well - if you aren’t swimming.  This, much like Mama Rose’s Naturals tends to “rinse off” if not rubbed in really really well.  I had some questions regarding the ingredients because initially they didn’t match (the website vs the tube) but Think Operations assured me that they were trying to use up misprinted tubes.

As far as safety in ingredients this one definitely is up to snuff.

I would also highly recommend against making your own sunscreens at home.  A lot of regulation needs to go into creating a sunscreen and you may be putting yourself at risk when working with sun-screening ingredients.

11. N. [6/17/10]

Brenna- I’ve had the same question on whether more affordable sunscreen is available! We need at least 4 tubes to start with as we’re all super-fair-skinend down here in a hot, sunny, southern state and shouldn’t be venturing outside for longer than 10 mins. unprotected. The thinkbaby/sport looked great..till I realized we’d be spending about $100 on 4 tubes with tax & shipping. I’ve been doing research for weeks and weeks and while I completely understand that safer ingredients are costlier, it’s a huge letdown not to be able to afford them. I still have yet to find a brand that’s both safe AND affordable..sigh.

Comment on this post

All comments are reviewed before being posted, and all spam comments are rejected. Any links published in comments are flagged as "no-follow" links, meaning they will not help anyone's search engine rankings.


not displayed, never shared
Accepted HTML <a href>, <b>, <i>

Help us study SIGG's EcoCare liner

Help us test Pampers Dry Max diapers




Browse Z Recommends
Looking for something?
The ZRecs Guide
    1360 products, 261 brands, and counting...


Get ZRecs’ monthly newsletter
More good stuff



Advertisements
Advertisements