The five cups below are among our
least favorite sippy and straw cups for kids ages two-point-fiveish to fiveish; elsewhere on Z Recommends you can see
how we ranked 24 sippy cups for babies and early toddlers, or what we named the
World's Worst Sippy Cup and the
World's Worst Straw Cup. Yes, we are obsessed with this stuff! It's why you love us...
A reminder of the rules of engagement for this division:
- Look to the scores to see why we ranked a cup the way we did; sometimes there were things we really liked about a product, but another category killed its chances at a good ranking.
- We did not leak-test straw cups except when their lids were closed, and all the cups in this showdown passed that test without incident.
- We'd love to hear your impressions of a product, whether you agree or disagree with our assessment - we (and other readers) love to hear how these products fared in your own home, as no design is perfect for everyone, and each is sure to have its advocates.
- Last but not least, don't forget that you'll have the chance at the end of the week to vote up a cup you see here or in our upcoming Middle Tier that you believe deserves Top Pick status!
And now, on to the rankings! Our Middle Tier and Top Picks for this division will follow tomorrow and Thursday.
Nuby No-Spill Flip It Straw Cup
Design: A 12-oz hourglass cup with a flip lid and three-part straw (top portion, firm straw, and straw extension).
Price: $3.50 |
Shop for Nuby's No-Spill Flip It Straw Cup on Amazon |
View all Nuby listings in the ZRecs Guide
Observations: Nuby's flip-top lid features a straw design that takes a bit more fiddling to thread through the opening than competing designs by Munchkin and cannot be completely disassembled, leaving some nooks and crannies that cannot be completely exposed for cleaning. The soft silicone straw tip will lose its shape over time and could lead to increased leaks, although the flip-it top offers a firm seal when closed. Our favorite thing about this cup is that the straw assembly's two sections make the components interoperable with a smaller Nuby straw cup, which made our Middle Tier of ratings (not yet published).
Ratings: Ease of Use and Care: 7. Durability: 8. Eye Appeal: 6. Value: 8. Total points: 29/40.
Zak! Designs Licensed Character Aluminum Bottle
Design: An aluminum bottle with a pop-up sport-style top and built-in cap with a flexible plastic loop to hold it on. Bright paints and popular licensed characters.
Price: $13. |
View all Zak! listings in the ZRecs Guide
Observations: The cap fits snugly but can take a bit of fussing to press into place, and the neck is narrow, which means ice is out of the question and cleaning can be a chore. Lid and bottle are interchangeable with Born Free's stainless steel bottle, but not with Sigg bottles.
Ratings: Ease of Use and Care: 6. Durability: 7. Eye Appeal: 8. Value: 6. Total points: 27/40.
Munchkin Mighty Grip Sports Bottle
Design: A plastic bottle with a "sport" style lid.
Price: $4 |
Shop for Munchkin's Mighty Grip Sports Bottle on Amazon |
View all Munchkin listings in the ZRecs Guide
Observations: What can you say about this bottle? The narrowed gripping area of the bottle makes this a bit of a pain to clean, and the silicone straw-like spout won't stand for much wear and tear. Plus, it's pretty ugly. Decent for the youngest segment of our demographic here, as it encourages straw-like mouth formations that are developmentally friendly, but otherwise, meh.
Ratings: Ease of Use and Care: 7. Durability: 5. Eye Appeal: 5. Value: 5. Total points: 22/40.
Nuby Sports Sipper Cup
Design: A plastic bottle with a "sport" style lid.
Price: $3 |
Shop for Nuby's Sports Sipper Cup on Amazon |
View all Nuby listings in the ZRecs Guide
Observations: Nuby's Sports Sipper doesn't have a lot to recommend it for young users other than its price tag. A "grippy" surface attached to the bottle's side doesn't add much for young users, and the super-soft spout deteriorates with use. See Munchkin's Mighty Grip listing above for more - these cups are functionally identical.
Ratings: Ease of Use and Care: 7. Durability: 5. Eye Appeal: 4. Value: 6. Total points: 22/40.
Born Free Stainless Steel Water Bottle
Design: A sturdy stainless-steel bottle in 9 or 12 ounces that has a sport style top opened by a front button, and a built-in cap with a flexible plastic loop to hold it on.
Price: $11/$14 |
Shop for Born Free's stainless steel water bottle on Amazon |
View all Born Free listings in the ZRecs Guide
Observations: Born Free's bottle is heavy-duty and has a clean look, but the logo sticker begins peeling after a few uses. The lid has a complex tangle of parts "under the hood" that allow the button to function, but the result is that they are exposed to the elements when the bottle is in use; for any liquid other than water, this means limited access to parts that can require cleaning. The cap fits snugly but sometimes with a bit of difficulty. The narrow neck means no ice for the kiddos, and it can be a pain to clean. Bottle and lid are interchangeable with the Zak! aluminum bottle, above, but not with Sigg bottles; the failure to make parts interoperable with Born Free's own bottles is a missed opportunity.
Ratings: Ease of Use and Care: 3. Durability: 7. Eye Appeal: 6. Value: 5. Total points: 21/40.